Michael Van Der Galien does a masterful job of fisking Libby Spencer over at Newshoggers. I'll let him cover this one:
At The Newshoggers. Libby writes: “Now I don’t want to get into a debate over whether Chavez is crazy, or a communist or pursuing the right policies for Venezuela. I honestly don’t know the answer to that, but I do know that he is a democratically elected leader who still enjoys significant support among the majority of that nation’s poor.” And, more importantly to the left, of course: “These are the people who take to the streets to protest Chavez and his programs to help his country’s poor and in a way one can understand their hatred for him. Chavez, whom they consider to be an upstart meztito, has instituted socialist policies that have redistributed the wealth and power more equally and it came at their expense.”
To top it off, she also compares Chavez to Bush: “It strikes me that all this talk about his tyranny is more than a little misplaced considering Venezuelans have more of a voice in their government than we do under Bush.”
Now that is misplaced. Lord knows I respect Libby and consider her a friend, but she’s way out there on this one.
Firstly, it does matter whether Chavez is a wannabe dictator or not.
Secondly, he’s amassing so much power that it’s already difficult to say whether the majority truly supports his reforms or not.
Read the rest. MVDG points out one glaring fact here that explains much in the reasoning of the left:
Fifthly, it never ceases to amaze me that for all the talk about freedom, many progressives actually only care about one thing: distribution of wealth.
That insight is probably one of the best one-line descriptions of the left yet. Because economic egalitarianism does appear to be the main driver for many, if not the vast majority on the far left. No other issue comes close to it and it trumps everything else. Literally any behavior can be excused so long as the economic misery is spread evenly. (And it is misery under the socialist system.) Excusing dictatorial behavior because the dictator promises to spread wealth around until everyone gets a pittance is a horrible standard to use. Comparing the absolute power Chavez is taking – by using a mask of democracy – to Bush's behavior is more than disingenuous. It is dangerous. It shows a complete disconnect with reality.
Which American broadcast network has been taken off the air by executive order? Which loud, dissenting American voices on the left have been silenced by gunfire? How much trade in blood diamonds has the American government indulged in? Oh, that's right, none of those things happened here, it happened in Venezuela.
I have quoted this line by Winston Churchill before: "The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of blessings; the inherent virtue of socialism is the equal sharing of miseries." Paying attention only to the even distribution of misery is a terrible philosophy.
UPDATE: Libby Spencer has updated her post with an explanation that she was misunderstood. Unfortunately, she then updates a second time and goes right off the deep end.
Meanwhile, even as my critics decry my equivalences, they make their own and suggest that dissent has not been stifled by this administration. Perhaps, they don't remember free speech zones, or how many have been arrested for wearing tshirts and holding signs, or that you can't get into a live speech by the president except by invitation. Perhaps they have forgotten the photos of injured demonstrators hit by rubber bullets. Oh wait, maybe they didn't see them because they only ran on Indymedia when they had their servers seized and didn't hear about them because almost all the low power broadcasters have been shut down by the FCC in deference to Clear Channel.
The servers seized thing may or may not be this event as documented by Truthout. I'd only point out that this is the same outfit that swore until they were blue in the face that Karl Rove had been indicted. I'd also just point out that not everything you read on the internet is Stone Tablet Truth® and that there may be more than a few liberties taken by the less than credible. But if you believe all you read, we know a good place to get some rat cheese.
Seriously, Libby, you really are making this worse – and sounding more unhinged by the minute.